Sline Archive

SENIOR LEADERS OF THE LUCKLESS IX CORPS – THE GOOD, THE BAD, & THE UGLY

On Wednesday July 15, 2009 at 7:30 pm the SDCWRT will hold its 275th meeting at Palisades Presbyterian Church, 6301 Birchwood St. San Diego, CA 92120.

Most people are familiar enough with the details of the Civil War to have heard of Major General Ambrose Everett  Burnside and the Battle of the Crater, and many others would recognize units such as the Iron Brigade or the “BloodySixth” Corps. But how well do you know Samuel Davis Sturgis or John Franklin Hartranft? Are you aware of the significance of the Battle at Fort Stedman and the role of the IX Corps in that action?

Ambrose Burnside

John Hartranft

The record of the Union Army IX Corps offers a glimpse into the cross-section of the experiences of the common soldier as well as its Generals. As a unit this Corps participated in many of the

pivotal battles and campaigns of the war, but it is probably best known for its central role in the ill-fated Battle of the Crater in 1864. In its three-year history, the IX Corps traveled across the Eastern and Western theaters and at times took heavy casualties in the course of their journey. We will examine their story by looking at their senior leaders – the Corps and Division commanders who led them into battle and who have largely faded into history.

Pete Young will focus on this select group of men who offer a fascinating range of personalities, capabilities, and backgrounds. Among them can be found a few of the better-known men who played major and minor roles in the war, as well as others who, while not as familiar, were nonetheless worthy of both acclaim and censure. Some were up to the demands of command and some were not. Each of them was given the opportunity to lead men in battle, and after the war ended those who survived went on to lead lives that continued to weave strong threads into the fabric of America.

Vote for your favorite 2008-2009

 “Presentation of the Year” Please Vote for one.

__       The Man from Michigan, Tracking an Old Soldier 

            July 16, 2008                         Pete Young

__       Shootout at Cherbourg       

            August 20, 2008                    Horace Dodd

__        The Harvard Regiment at Gettysburg

            October 15, 2008                  Mark Shapiro

__        Mercy in the Madness

            November 19, 2008              Father Dennis Mikulanis, STD

__       California Columns

            January 21, 2009                  Gene Armistead

 __     Civil War Camp Life

            March 18, 2009                     Dave Tooley

__       Lee, Stuart and the Road to Perdition

            April 15, 2009                       Pedro Garcia

__       Equines of the Civil War

            May 20, 2009                         Gene Armistead

Please vote for the best presentation of 2007-2008 by one of our local members and send to Bill Cooper at P.O. BOX 22369, SAN DIEGO, CA 92192-0369; give it to Bill at the regular meeting; or send Bill your vote on the internet at trolley@cox.net. We will also be voting at the August 20^th meeting.

Don't Forget To VOTE.

June Meeting by Travis Fuqua

The SDCWRT was honored to have author Larry Tagg present on his book, The Unpopular Mr. Lincoln on June 17, 2009. His book is amongst the first of its kind to discuss the popularity of President Lincoln during his presidency. For those who grew up and were educated in the years after the Civil War, not a day goes by where we do not encounter the image of Lincoln, the demi-god. He is on our currency, in our monuments, and even in many of our hearts as among the best presidents we ever had—perhaps second only to the great General Washington himself. During his presidency, however, he was one of the most reviled men in the nation. His unpopularity in the Confederacy is a given, but he was no more popular in the North. The following is an account of the public’s perception of Mr. Lincoln in the North as seen mostly through newspaper editorials and other written accounts.

Mr. Tagg Presenting on His Book "The Unpopular Mr. Lincoln"

            President Lincoln’s unpopularity began long before his time in the White House. It begins with the manner in which presidential candidates were selected in the years before 1972. In those days, there were no primary elections as there are now, but party bosses would gather and select a candidate who would in turn be that party’s nominee for the presidency. In the days before the Civil War, the nation was ablaze with the question of slavery and many parties found it difficult to nominate the famous candidates as their opinions on slavery would cause more controversy. This led to many mediocre candidates and presidents such as Franklin Pierce and James Buchannan, who has often been called the worst president ever for his handling of the secession crisis of 1860-1861. By the time of the 1860 election, many were cynical about the mediocrity of the candidates. The Republicans picked a relatively unknown candidate by the name of Abraham Lincoln who was a lawyer and had been in the House of Representatives some years ago and an unsuccessful candidate for the Senate. The only image that people had of him was the “rail splitter” and rural “man of the people” image that had been circulated. He did not speak during the campaign and did not actively campaign either, but nonetheless, he was elected in November of 1860. His unknown status was the first issue people had with him.

            The Election of 1860 had two candidates who split the Democratic vote along with a third independent candidate almost ensuring Lincoln’s victory. He only won with 39.8 percent of the vote, which is worse than the loser in many other presidential elections. As soon as he won, the South panicked and there were fears of what Lincoln would do as president. Many in the South feared that he would fill the government with abolitionists through the spoils system and then use these people to bring about greater pressure to end slavery. Others feared that Lincoln would be the culmination of the mediocre presidents of the previous decade and lead the United States to a path of decline. There were even others still who derided his appearance saying that he was too tall, too thin, to awkward, and even too ugly. People called him a “huge skeleton in clothes”. They criticized his posture, movements, and even the size of his hands and feet. There was little in the new president that people liked. To make matters worse, Lincoln did not take much care in his appearance and his clothes were often unkempt and people never failed to take note of such. This and his manners alienated the educated and cultured people of the East. The harsh comments about his appearance would be unthinkable today and make the editorials of today’s newspapers look sedate.

            By the beginning of 1861, President-Elect Lincoln had many obstacles before him other than the public’s perception of him. Several states in the Deep South had seceded from the union and President Buchanan’s actions (or lack of them) worsened the situation by the day. By the time Lincoln made it to office, the nation was very near to shattering and it needed another George Washington, not Lincoln, who they perceived as utterly incompetent. Lincoln’s popularity took an even further dip when he came to the City of Washington for the inauguration and slipped into the city under cover the of darkness to avoid a potential assassination plot. Even at that time, he was unpopular enough to have to worry about assassins. Many saw this secrecy as cowardice and many more editorials derided Lincoln for slipping into Washington. Upon his inauguration, Lincoln was just as unpopular coming into the office as President Nixon was upon resigning the office in the fallout of the Watergate Scandal.

            The war did not help with Lincoln’s popularity. The failure of many Federal campaigns cost him even more in popularity and many people openly felt that he was completely incompetent and unable to properly preside over the nation during the time of crisis. Following the Federal victory at the Battle of Antietam in September of 1862, Lincoln issued the Emancipation Proclamation. It was obviously poorly received in the South, but it was just as poorly received in some areas of the North. Many felt that the war had been over the status of the union and not really slavery, but Lincoln’s attempt at emancipating the slaves would further drive the Confederate states away and further drive the nation apart. In addition, many people feared that such a declaration during a century when the president’s power was limited would undoubtedly lead to further despotism by Lincoln. The Emancipation Proclamation and further military losses later in the year were a blow to Lincoln and the Republicans as they lost many seats in Congress during the midterm election in November of 1862.

            When President Lincoln made the Emancipation Proclamation official on January 1, 1863, the divide became even greater. Many states in the North that relied upon slavery and the South began to question Lincoln and openly considered joining the Confederacy. Lincoln was threatened with the loss of many Midwestern states to the Confederacy and much of their support for the war effort dried up. This divide in the North allowed for the Democratic Copperheads to rise in power and question the Republicans’ management of the war. Also, due to a lack of manpower as a result of the Midwestern states lack of support, Lincoln had to create a draft program, which caused the Draft Riots in New York City in July of 1863. It may have seemed that the division of the nation in 1861 was the greatest danger to the country, but now many considered Lincoln was the greater threat. They saw his removal of rights and liberties as a threat to the Constitution and they feared that the nation and its Constitution would fracture and fail. Lincoln was only saved by the Federal victory at Gettysburg in July of 1863.

            Lincoln’s reprieve would not last. Following the reversals during the Wilderness Campaign in May of 1864 and others, Lincoln’s popularity dipped again. The nation began to fear that the war would never end. As the election neared, the Wade-Davis Manifesto was issued which spoke out against the despotism of Lincoln. Lincoln was re-nominated at the Republican Convention, though, but it was through his manipulation of the spoils system that he obtained such. His competition in the election was General George McClellan who called for peace. Lincoln began to worry about his chances of winning the election and August of 1864 was perhaps his lowest point. The fall of Atlanta in September of 1864 helped morale and helped Lincoln immensely. He was still worried about his chances of winning and helped Nevada join the union as it was loyal to him. It was feared that their state constitution would not reach Washington in time for the election if it was sent overland. Just over a week before the 1864 election, Nevada had its 16,500-word constitution telegraphed to Washington at the cost of $4,300, making it one of the longest and costliest telegraph transmissions ever. By the time of the election, however, conditions had changed for President Lincoln and Nevada’s impact on the election was negligible. In addition, for the first time, soldiers in the field were allowed to cast votes for president in some states and their votes greatly assisted Lincoln as he had gained their support with the draft. Lincoln ended up winning the election with a little over half of the votes.

            The beginning of 1865 began to look brighter for Lincoln and there were many signs that the war would end sooner than later. People began to attribute the turnaround to Lincoln, but there were those who did not. There were even those who feared another four years of Lincoln and began to call for ways to get rid of him—even through assassination. The war did finally end beginning on April 9, 1865 with General Lee’s surrender and Lincoln’s popularity began to rise. His moderate views on Reconstruction in the heated times did not help his popularity however. On April 14, 1865, President Lincoln was shot in the head by southern sympathizer John Wilkes Booth and died at 7:22 the next morning. He was the first president to be assassinated. Even in death, Lincoln was hated by some as they were happy he was gone so they could proceed with their more harsh Reconstruction schemes while others were glad the tyrant was dead.

            President Lincoln was largely unpopular throughout the whole of his presidency. He was saved by his assassination which caused people to see him as a martyr. They saw him along with Moses not being able to see the Promised Land of a free and reunited nation. In one popular print he was supposedly lifted to heaven by the great General Washington. Lincoln came to symbolize freedom while his southern assassin came to represent treachery. His funeral train back to Springfield, Illinois became a symbol of the fanaticism of Victorian mourning. Only then did Lincoln become the president that we adore today as a savior of our country and a symbol of freedom. Lincoln was a capable president according to Mr. Tagg, because he did more with the least political capital than any president before or since. He truly was a great politician.

Mr. Cooper Presenting Mr. Tagg with a Certificate of Appreciation After His Presentation

Treasurers report by Paul A Champlin

Profit & Loss by Paul A Champlin

Feature Article

Libby And How We Got Out Of It

(submitted by SDCWRT member

Curtis Dryer – family papers )

BY

ALBERT WILLIAM BACHELER

Part III

Trusting to the innate sense of justice in the slave, we did not hesitate to confide to hem our secret.  The story seemed to hasten their endeavors to make us comfortable.  The family was soon astir, and the matron quickly mixed cornmeal into a hoe-cake, raked the hot ashes aside, patted the cake into passable shape, and tossing it among the embers soon had it ready for us.  “Good Lor’ massa, af yer’s only tols dis yer when yer fuss come, mabbe yer’d don gon and had dis hoe-cake eat up to now,” said the kind creature, half apologizing for her tardiness in preparing the meal.  Never before was food so sweet; for though a little of Pryor’s bread still remained, we had found small opportunity to eat, compared with the comfort of this humble home.  The meal over, we talked of shelter near by, and the man of the family, a brawny Negro, a plantation hand of the best type, offered to stow us away on a loft of loose boards over the fireplace.  We slept out the entire day in comparative comfort.  On coming down the ladder at nightfall, the good fellow told us that his mistress had spoken of soldiers who had called at the house to inquire for prisoners that were said to have escaped two nights before from Libby.  So we knew we were missed and that no stone would be left unturned to retake us.

“Endu’ in de wah sah, we’s cullored fo’ks cum right soon,” said our host as we bade his good-by.  We now pushed for the Chickahominy, and crossed it near midnight a few miles west of Mechanicsville, where we leaped the stream without difficulty, it being hardly more than a brook.  Once over, we turned southward determined to use the stream as a guide, as we knew it would finally bring us to the James, where we were sure of finding Union troops.  As the night wore away we again sought the help of Negroes at a plantation cabin.  This time, after getting warmed and clothing dried, we were conducted to an open shed, fifty rods or more from the house, where the man of the family stowed us away deep under the cornstalks that filled the shed.  Giving us a large hot stone for our feet and piling above us many an armful of the fodder, he bade us keep quiet, and promised to come for us after nightfall.

About four in the afternoon the sound of voices roused us and we heard a car approaching the corn-rick.  “Ise dun gwine ter gib did yer mule no o; co’n, case he’s jus fass getting good fer nuffin,” said the voice of our friend, the boss hand on the place.  A gruff answer we could not make out was made to his remark, and then we heard the cart back up to the stalks, and the two of them began to load.  Their voices grew more and more distinct as the pile over our heads grew thinner.  “Wha fur yer gwine ter kill dat ar mule?” complained the slave.  “Cart’s dun loaded nuff and mo’.”  But the master bade him keep on; he even took the fork himself and eased the slave for a moment.  Again and again the two men walked over us, and once the fork tines passed through Thompson’s trousers, but luckily missed wounding him.

At last the expostulations of the slave in the mule’s behalf had their effect, and the cart drove off.  We breathed freer for the moment, but would cart and master return?  Ben pulled his jack-knife from his pocket, and opening it scanned the only weapon of defense we possessed.  Then, shaking his head, said, “It’s no use.  Back we’re going as sure as thunder and we’ll be gobbled.”  We saw there was nothing for it but to be out and off, so gathering our traps, and seeing a piece of woods nearby, we ran for it, and seemed to have escaped observation.  Though it still lacked two hours of dark, we concluded to continue our tramp.  A light snow had fallen during the day, and half melting not only quickly soaked our army brogans, but also made it almost impossible for us to halt for rest with any degree of comfort.  We had marched an hour perhaps, when skirting a piece of woods, we suddenly came to a junction of three roads, and saw before us a mill on the bank of a small stream.  The ruins of a much larger mill were near at hand, and we soon learned that this was Gaine’s Mill that had figured so prominently in the seven days’ fight before Richmond.  Some men were at work on the mill, and a squad of Confederate cavalry was cooking at a fire nearby.  So sudden had been our approach that almost before we knew it we were in plain view of the group, and not ten rods away.  I would have sold my chances cheap, and Ben afterwards told me that he saw Castle Thunder for an instant as plainly as it he were in it.  “Come on,” whispered he, “It’s no use running, but remember to let me do the talking.”  I gladly notice that the boldness of our maneuvers had completely thrown them off their guard.  We asked each other in turn the natural questions at such a meeting.  Ben told them that we were officers of the Eleventh Virginia Infantry, and had volunteered to go as spies into the Yankee lines to find out the progress Dutch Gap canal was making.

Our dress of Union blue seemed to confirm our story, and in fact Thompson volunteered the information that we had secured the clothing the better to escape observation.  “Do you know Captain Polk of the Eleventh?” said the officer in charge of the picket.  “Well, I reckon,” replied Thompson, “he belongs to my mess.  I left him only a day or two ago.  Fine fellow, cap.”  A part of this was literally true, for in exchanging the courtesies of the picket line at Port Walthall; we had met the officer referred to.  Questions over, we were invited to share the supper of the party, and regaled ourselves with bacon roasted on a stick over the fire, and corn bread cooked at a neighboring farmhouse.  With many wishes for the success of our venture, and a promise on our part to call on them on our way back and relate our adventures among the Yanks, we parted the best of friends.  “Take care of yourselves, boys, them Yanks are mighty sharp,” wee the last words that followed us.  Moving down the road so long as the light of their campfire was in sight, as soon as possible we struck for the woods and after getting under cover took up the double-quick for a mile or more without a halt.  By that time the excitement of our adventure had subsided enough to allow us to speak, and Ben turning to me said, “Bach, another one like that’ll be too much for me.”

Early that night, the third since our escape, and only a couple of miles from Gaine’s Mills, we found ourselves tumbling about among the entrenchment’s and bomb-proofs of Cold Harbor battle-field.  A field where, on the 3^rd of June preceding, our regiment at the head of Humphrey’s Division, had made the fatal charge that cost us more than half our men in the short space of five minutes.  No Twelfth New Hampshire boy hears the name Cold Harbor without a shudder to this day.

Traces of the savage fight were lying about everywhere.  Canteens, cartridge boxes, shattered muskets, and here and there the bleaching bones of comrades looked up into our faces, white and distinct in the darkness.  Damp and chilly as it was we could have enjoyed a short nap, even in that place, had I not, in groping about for a smooth spot, struck something hard and round, and upon carrying it to the light, seen the grinning features of a skull looking at me with it s sightless eyes.  We could endure fatigue better than sleep with such companionship, and resumed again our weary tramp.  It was a hideous night; blackness all about, but light enough for us to distinguish the scattered bones of the dead which now and then caused us to stumble, and wonder what the poor owners of seven months before would have said to this rude intrusion on their long sleep.  At 2 o’clock that night a light ahead gave warning of a dwelling.  It proved to be a Negro cabin.  Within, father, mother, and three adult daughters were at work at their task of shelling corn, a task, which they assured us, must be finished before they could receive their rations of food for the next day.  Despite their own dire necessities, they begged us to remain the day at their cabin and offered to share with us their scanty fare.  With some hesitation we concluded to stay, worn out we were, that, though family continued their usual occupation, neither Ben nor myself knew what was occurring.  Early the succeeding night, after thanking our host, and promising to free them from their bondage when we had conquered the rebs, we were on our journey; and getting bolder with our increasing distance from Richmond, we determined to take the roads instead of avoiding them as we had hitherto done.  By 10 o’clock we had reached Barker’s Mill, the scene of another flight of the Peninsular Campaign, and an hour later were passing the ruins of Tyler’s House.  The two roads leading to Sumner’s grapevine bridge over the Chickahominy River were left to our right.  We had learned that these bridges were no longer passable and hurrying on our way we crossed the Richmond & York Railroad and struck the highway leading to Bottom’s Bridge.  There we had determined to recross the stream and strike for camps of our troops that we knew to be on the north bank of the James, and some twelve miles distant.  About 3 in the morning we approached the bridge, and much to our surprise found a bright campfire at the center of the road and about four rods from the father end of the bridge.  Horses were picketed near by; their saddles on, betokening readiness for prompt movement.  A sentry stood dreamily looking into the fire at his feet, his carbine at “secure”.  Thompson and I hastily retreated into the thicket by the roadside.  We discussed the situation in whispers.  There are two alternatives open to us; a tramp of seventy miles down the peninsula to Fortress Monroe with all the risks of capture such as we had already experienced, or an equally hazardous attempt at crossing the bridge in the face of an armed guard, with almost the dead certainly of bringing us to Richmond.  Pros and cons are carefully weighed.  So evenly balanced seem the chances that we cannot make a choice.  “Lie still, Ben,” said I, “while I go out and look them over again.”  Leaving him n the woods I crept along on my hands and knees to the end of the bridge nearest us.  The road is an embankment as it approaches the bridge, and high above the level.  The river, a black, ugly stream flows sluggishly by.  It is fifty feet or more in breadth.  Any one attempting to cross must move the entire distance in the face of that picket standing there by his fire, and nearing him at every step.  There are six men, at least, under their blankets near the fire.  If there were but one we might dash upon him and overpower him.  I return to my companion and report.  “There is one chance in a thousand,” I said, “and that is the best I can make it.”  Ben suggests lots; agreed.  He cuts two twigs, — “Long one means the long road: short one, the bridge.”  He fixes them; I draw.  It is the long stick!  Off we start down the long pike, trying to think we have done the best n choosing as we have.  We can hardly drag one foot after the other.  Our feet are parboiled with their constant soaking; every motion of the body is torture; the terrible strain of the last five days has begun to tell, not only on our physical endurance but on our will power as well.  “Ben.”   I say at last, “this is slow murder.  I’d as soon starve in Libby as walk myself into the grave.  What do you say to trying the bridge?”  “I’m agreed,” said he, and back we tramp over the half-mile we have just come.  We agree that I shall lead, and Ben keep close behind; if the guard challenges us we are to rush for the woods, and run the chances of his missing us when he fires.  Once on the bridge we drop on hands and knees cat-like across.  Every inch brings us nearer the picket; he stands like a statue.  He seems to nod once, but as I wait for another look he stoops down and tosses some brands into the fire.  We move on; each thinks the other makes twice the noise he needs to.  We are at the end of the bridge.  My eyes are almost bursting from their sockets as I watch that man at the fire.  A yard more and we are safe!  It is the longest yard I have ever traveled; it ends at last, and I creep down the embankment at the roadside farthest from the guard.  Ben sticks close behind, and is the last to be out of danger.  We steel away through the bushes and take the first long breath, and as we do so, the sentry for some reason, we never knew what, rouses his sleeping companions and they stand to arms.  A mile away under the shelter of some pines we stretch out on the pine needles and are fast asleep in a twinkling.

The sun was high before either of us awoke.  We concluded it was best to lay off for the day and not run the chance of meeting scouting parties of the rebs.  As soon as darkness permitted we were again on the road, and happy in the thought that it was our last night out.  At the first farmhouse we reached, we very incautiously walked up to the door and knocked.  A white woman appeared, evidently the mistress of the house.  I asked for food, she answered by asking who we were and why we were there in that plight.  Ben interposed with the same story he had used at Gaine’s Mills with such good effect.  It was all to no purpose.  “You ‘uns ar jes Yanks, you don’t talk like we’uns down here’n Henraker,” was all the answer we got in reply to our request for food.  “We’ve caught a Tartar,” I whispered to Thompson, and without pressing our claims o the woman’s larder, we bade here good night and hurried off through the fields towards the James.  Directly we reached some Negro quarters belonging to the same plantation, and making our way in asked for hoecakes.  The women began to prepare it and while we made ourselves comfortable at the fire a Negro lad ran in, out of breath, and told his mother that his mistress, as soon as we were out of the house, had dispatched a son to some neighbors a mile away to rouse the lads to be after some Yanks that had been there.  An older son was home on furlough from the Petersburg lines and had gone to a dance at a neighbor’s.  “It’s time we were out of this,” said Ben, and without waiting for the hoe-cakes, now about half done, we made good time over the fields and through the woods for a couple of miles until the rough jungle forces us to take to the road again.  We tramped along for half an hour, perhaps, neither of us speaking meanwhile, when an overpowering desire came over me to rest.  I declared to Ben that I would go no further till I had rested.  He urged our keeping on; we are nearly through, said he; only seven miles and we should reach Harrison’s and then we could rest for good; but I am stubborn.  Ben was as determined as I.  “Then I am going on alone,” he said, and started ahead.  I walked into the open field by the roadside, fifty feet or so, and stretched out on my canvas.  Thompson after moving on a little changed his mind, came back where I was, and lay down by my side.

We were lying there quietly, with the moon looking us in the face, it being now between ten and eleven, when the rumble of a wagon fell on our ears.  Nearer and nearer it drew to us, coming from the direction in which we were bound.  We should have met it had we kept on.  As the team reached up we saw it was a countryman, whether black or white we could not distinguish, which a load of wood.  His mules stopped to breath in front of us, and almost it the same instant a cavalryman coming from our rear drew rein in front of the team.  He was mounted on a gray horse, and heavily armed.  “Have yer seen a couple of fellows on the road as yer come along?” said he, addressing the teamster.  The man answered that he had not.  The soldier then went on to say that two chaps that looked like escaped prisoners had stopped at his mother’s an hour before to ask for food, and not being granted it had hurried off through the field.  “One of them’, said he, evidently describing Ben, “was a stout fellow with a Yank’s cap and heavy moustache, and the other shore and slim like, and with a slouched hat.  They both had Yank’s uniforms,” he added, “and carried some sore of blankets over their shoulders.”  To the two fugitives who were being thus accurately described, this conversation was becoming decidedly interesting.  It is needless to say that I never hugged any five feet of ground closer in my life.  Neither of us stirred.  There we lay in the open field in bright moonlight, and took in every word.  One glance of the rider towards us and he must have seen us.  To our infinite relief he said at last, “I reckon as how the rascals must have turned off on Long Bridge road,” and then turning his horse he kept the mule team company on the road to our rear.  We listened to their voices as they died away in the distance, and congratulating ourselves on this last narrow escape, kept on our way, Thompson ahead and looking out for dangers in advance, and I behind with an occasional backwards glance to warn of trouble from the rear.

Faint streaks of dawn were appearing in the east when Ben caught sight of a mounted horseman standing statue-like in the road in advance.  Fearful of making a mistake, we reconnoitered for some time before venturing to make ourselves known.  Negros had told us that a colored regiment with gray horses were doing picket duty at the Landing.  Ben finally sang out, “Hello there, don’t shoot, we’re friends, we want to come in.”  “Corporal of the guard!” answered the picket without noticing us directly.  In a moment the corporal and three men charged down on us at a gallop with carbines ready for instant service.  However, we had no difficulty in proving who we were to their satisfaction, and in a few minutes we were made welcome by the Eight United States Colored Cavalry.  Once back with the picket reserve we were furnished hot coffee and extra blankets, and turned in for sleep —and such sleeping as we did that morning!  On waking, someone passed us a mirror: neither Ben nor I could recognize ourselves, and no wonder.  My own weight had fallen off; as I afterwards learned, from one hundred and forty-five to ninety-six pounds, and Ben’s in like proportion.  Our complexions has sallowed, and the vile stench of the prison hung about us for weeks despite new uniforms and frequent baths.

To tell how we took the boat the next day to Chapin’s Farm where our corps was then stationed; how the boys turned out as we drew near the camp, and boasted us on their shoulders and rode us into quarters perched high in the air; how the officers made us welcome to their mess; how General Weitzel ordered us a thirty days’ furlough; how, while at home, we received commissions as officers; how when we took Richmond the following April, I paid old Pryor a visit and relieved him of some of the arms he used to flourish in our faces —all these are things not germane to my story, which amounts to this, that next to the wear and tear of life in Libby and all that that implies, is the wear and tear of getting out of Libby and all that that includes.

Letters to the Editor

Mr Editor,

I am prompted to write to you in appreciation of the fine program given Tuesday night by Sacramento High School teacher, Larry Tagg, on the “Unpopular Mr Lincoln.” Larry gave a very good presentation, and I’m sure that his book adds much to his insightful look back at President Lincoln before martyrdom. It was a casual program, just what the SDCWRT is all about. We aren’t History teachers, we’re history students.

Recently, Bob Sigafoes, has returned. He’s the guy who got it all started. A look around the meeting shows many faces of people who have been members for many years. The Civil War is the subject, and our group has done a respectful job of respecting the event.

As a member, I want to thank the Board members, because without their commitments the SDCWRT would cease to exist. It would be a loss, and the subject is too important and interesting to not have such a public forum. I kid Dave Tooley, calling him King George, as he nears the number of years as President as FDR, but he does what no one wants to do, and does it well. Without Paul Champlin, things would be a mess. Bill is an excellent program chairman, as well a very funny man, and I can’t imagine the SDCWRT without Al Haun. Carla is indispensable, keeps us connected to the CW community, and Larry, Curtis, and Mikey give so much to the group.

I certainly miss Jordan, but he knew that Father Dennis was ably in charge. Many others help the SDCWRT maintain itself and deserve mention, but to me, Mr Editor, you are “the man”. Dave, great job. I have been there, and putting the newsletter together every week is time consuming, and a major responsibility. From one member, on behalf of all, thanks.

Rich Marcell

How Do I Pronounce this word

How is “Garesche ” pronounced?   - Come to our meeting and learn the unique ways of saying Garesche.

June Program

THE UNPOPULAR MR. LINCOLN By Larry Tagg          

Abraham Lincoln

On Wednesday June 17, 2009 at 7:30 pm the SDCWRT will hold its 274th meeting at Palisades Presbyterian Church, 6301 Birchwood St. San Diego, CA 92120.

“The most revered American president was, during his four years in office, the most reviled. The story of Abraham Lincoln’s presidency is a classic underdog story: a review of Civil War diaries, letters, editorials and recollected remarks reveals an intensity of venom toward Lincoln that is startling, even to a modern reader steeped in the political milieu of Ann Coulter and Rush Limbaugh.”

Larry Tagg was born in Lincoln, Illinois; he graduated from the University of Texas at Austin. A bass player/singer of world renown, and was co-founded and enjoyed substantial commercial success with “Bourgeois Tagg” in the mid-1980s. He went on to play bass for Todd Rundgren, Hall and Oates, and other acts. He currently teaches high school English and drama in Sacramento, California. Larry’s latest book is The Unpopular Mr. Lincoln. He is also the author of The Generals of Gettysburg, a selection of the Military Book Club.

May Meeting by Travis Fuqua

Gene Armistead

Gene Armistead presented Equines in the Civil War on May 20, 2009. This month’s presentation was about the roles that equines—horses, mules, and donkeys—played in the Civil War from the cavalry charge to the quartermaster’s wagon train. When we think of horses and war, we often think of romantic and daring cavalry charges, but equines played a far more important role in the war. The Civil War, of course, took place in the days before automobiles, trucks, and tanks, and thus everything that could not be moved on the limited railroad network had to be moved by equines. Men had to charge into battle on the backs of horses.

As mentioned before, the most famous image of equines is that of the cavalry. The cavalry in the Civil War was harsh as the horses and the men were constantly in the line of fire. Generals often had more than one horse to ensure that a fresh one was always ready for him. Sometimes, an officer lost a horse in battle and had to find a replacement and sometimes, he could even loose several horses in battle. The life of cavalry horses was very harsh and their survival rate was only about four months. Given this and the number of cavalry regiments, there was a need for almost two and a half million cavalry horses during the war.

Another important use of horses in the war was that of artillery horse. Some artillery horses pulled the artillery pieces to the field of battle and the others pulled the supplies necessary for the field pieces. Artillery horses often found themselves under fire as it was a sure method to cripple the enemy’s artillery by immobilizing it. Artillery horses fared better than their cavalry counterparts and lasted an average of seven and a half months. Given this expectancy and the number of artillery units on both sides, there was a need for almost a half a million artillery horses.

Gene Armistead talking Civil War equines up

Perhaps the most important use of equines in the war was in supplying the army. The quartermaster needed tremendous numbers of mules to supply the armies and the ratio of mules to men varied depending on the roads and the severity of the campaign, but by 1864, the Federal army overall needed one animal for every two men. The horses themselves also had great supply needs for feed and water. Mules were found to be better than horses as they could work better with cheaper and less feed. Horses were also used to pull ambulances and pharmacies and mules were even used to carry wounded soldiers when an ambulance was unavailable or inconvenient. The Civil War created a need for almost four million horses and mules. This is compared to the combined Federal and Confederate army of three and a quarter million men.

Paying for and supplying the animals was another question. Most horses and mules ranged in price form about one hundred dollars to two hundred. Sometimes, wartime inflation and the fame of the horse could drive the price as high as $4,600, which was the appraised price of General Lee’s famous horse, Traveller. By the end of the war, the Federal Army had spent 130 million dollars on horses and mules. Each side always needed more horses than it could ever hope to obtain. There were no specific breeding programs given the sudden nature of the war and neither side was particular about the breed of horse it required, although certain units specified certain colors or types of horses, but mostly for a dramatic effect.

The Federal government set up six horse depots throughout the country to obtain and distribute horses, but there were notorious cases of corruption and incompetence and many horses that were acquired by the Federal government were unusable. When the supply depots could not manage, men often had to scour the countryside and take whatever equines they could find. Confederate forces had even more difficulty given that Confederate officers were supposed to supply their own horses in addition to the general lack of resources in the Confederacy. Whenever Confederate forces were in the north and took northern farm animals, they found that they were better suited for pulling plows rather than riding.

Bill Cooper presenting Appreciation Certificate to Gene Armistead

Many horses and men in the war developed a relationship and other horses became almost as famous as their masters. The aforementioned horse, Traveller, of General Lee began its life before the war named after a Mississippi Congressmen by the name of Jefferson Davis. “Jeff Davis” later ended up with Lee after a series of owners and was renamed Traveller. He died in 1871 and his skeleton was placed on display before being buried in the 1970s. Some other general’s horses from both sides of the war have either been entirely stuffed or have had parts stuffed and are currently on display. One could argue that these stuffed remains are the last survivors of the Civil War. The horses that served in the war were in some ways equally as brave as those who rode them into the field of battle.

Feature Article

(submitted by SDCWRT member

Curtis Dryer – family papers )

BY

ALBERT WILLIAM BACHELER

Part II

Libby Prison, Richmond VA

It would be quite unlikely that men in circumstances like these should fail to discuss, in subdued tones but ever deepening interest, the chances of escape and the means for accomplishing it.  One of the men captured with me was Ben Thompson, a native of Wolfeborough, NH.  He was one of the best specimens of the traditional Yankee, —shrewd as a lawyer, keen at trade as a Jew, full of resources, and plucky.  He lacked all reverence for dignity or rank, and would always succeed in worming his way into the confidence of officers with appearing intrusive.

         The following story told at Ben’s expense, just before our capture, illustrates his character better than any words of mine.  Ben had been detailed for picket duty one day, and scenting a chance to turn a honest shekel, he filled his haversack with commissary coffee, and watching his opportunity traded it off during the day with the “Johnnies” for tobacco and papers.  Next day Ben was sick, “unfit for service”, so the surgeon said, and was missing from sight for some hours.  Everybody supposed he was asleep in his tent.  Nothing of the sort.  With his surgeon’s release from duty in his pocket, and his haversack on his shoulder, Ben struck for the James, hired a darkly to row him across in his dugout, and turned up late in the forenoon at Dutch Gap canal, then two thirds dug across the narrow tongue of land where Butler was cutting off a seven mile reach of the river.  For two hours Ben drove a thriving trade, and found the troops at work in the canal, hungry for both news and weed.  He was nearly done with this traffic, and had begun to congratulate himself on the generous pile of greenbacks in his possession, when General Butler, with an orderly or two at his heels, made his way on foot into the “big ditch”.  Thompson failed to see the General until he was close upon him, and knowing that he had been driving a contraband trade, he naturally feared a confiscation of his gains.  However, drawing a bunch of choice Havana’s from the depth of his haversack, a reserve fund apparently provided for an emergency, he ran up to the General with, “Good morning, General, I’ve been trying to find you for a week, for I did want you to try some of my fresh cigars, and I hope you’ll do me the honor to accept them with my complements”.  Before the General could refuse or accept the proffer, a ten-inch bomb from one of their mortars was dropped by the “Johnnies” in somewhat anxious proximity to the group.  Exploding as it buried itself in the ground, it did not further damage than to cover the General and his escort with mud.  But Ben, taking advantage of the exciting moment, cried out, “Good God, General, if that’s the manners you show a kindly disposed person like myself, the sooner I’m out of this, the better!” and with the words he ran like mad out of the canal, and was soon lost to view around a bend of the river.  

Seeing Ben in a brown study one day, a fortnight after we reached Libby, I inquired what he was thinking about.  Instead of any direct reply, he asked if I knew anything about shoemaking, and on my reply in the affirmative, he told me of a chance turnkey Pryor had offered him to make shoes for the Confederacy.  “And who knows,” said he, “but there’ll be a chance for us to skedaddle out of this, if once we get into the shop.”  Next morning thirty of us were detailed as shoemakers, and found ourselves in a building adjoining the main prison hard at work on shoes for the rebel army.  There was a partial division of labor among the gangs that brought the stitching to me and the fitting of the soles to Thompson.  Early in our work I noticed Ben went through a curious process of cutting deeply across the outer sole of every shoe, on the reverse die at the front, where hank and heal meet.  Of course it ruined the shoe, which would do well if it served the wearer while he was walking away from the quartermaster’s.  “That’s my mark,” said Ben, at my inquiry.  “Escape valve, you know, for the guilty conscience of a fellow at work aiding and abetting the enemies of his country.”  Neither of us ever met a “Johnnie” afterwards, but we ached to ask him if he had ever worn any of the patent brands manufactured by the Yanks at Libby.

Across Water Street from our shop was a large warehouse used for any overflow of prisoners, but empty at the time we were there, on the second floor of which, is a small room, old Pryor kept a variety store.  It was a sort of perquisite to his office as prison keeper, and aided in eking out a scanty salary.  Pryor was accustomed almost daily to conduct squads of half dozen prisoners to this store, and sell them bread, apples, and other eatables.  His prices were outrageous, fifty cents for an apple, one dollar a loaf for bread, two dollars for apple-pie baked in an ordinary saucer.  This process of sale was thought altogether safe, as the warehouse was within prison enclosure and always surrounded by the line of sentries.  When Ben and I had studied the situation and formed our plans for escape, we broached the matter to our fellow-shoemakers and endeavored to induce some of them to join us.  But the danger of recapture and the terrors of Castle Thunder proved stronger than our arguments.  It was fortunate for us that they were so, for we learned by experience that the smaller the number in an escaping parties the less likely were the rebs to pursue and retake them.  However, nearly the entire shop wrote anonymous letters to their friends, and these we agreed to deliver to the mails within a reasonable time, Ben remarking that if anything happened to that particular penny-post he should bring suit in the court of claims against the Southern Confederacy.

December 12, the day we had chosen for out attempt, was dark and stormy.  Holding off as late in the afternoon as we dared, we informed Pryor that we needed something to eat, and with four other comrades who were in our secret were taken over the street to the store.  Thompson and I made our purchase first, and then stepping aside, our companions engaged the keeper’s attention while we noiselessly crept up a second flight of stairs to the third story.  There we were fortunate enough to find an immense pile of condemned tent-cloth, much of it with the stamp of the United States upon it.  Working our way deep into the pile, we anxiously waited for any sounds that would indicate we had been missed.  Comrades have since told me that Pryor at once inquired for us, but on being assured that we had returned to the shop seemed satisfied and returned the remainder without further questions.  Six hours of weary waiting followed, for we had agreed to wait for midnight, as the safest hour for our attempt.  Nothing broke the dull monotony of the time save the sleepy “Post No. 1, all’s well!” of the drowsy sentinels, carried in turn around the prison by each succeeding sentry.  Soon after twelve we were astir.  Cutting the tent-cloth into long strips we braided a triple strand into a passably strong rope of some thirty feet I length.  Fastening one end to a table we had found near by, we dropped the other end from a window.  It was short by ten feet, but we had no difficulty in dropping that height.  Thomson slid down first and I followed.  Once at the bottom we found ourselves inside a board fence fifteen feet high, with the smooth side next the prison.  Luckily, however, there were lying about the remains of the boards and timbers of which the fence had been built, and having piled these up cob-house fashion, I mounted the pile, and Ben mounted my shoulders.  He could just reach the fence top, and being muscular he was over in a twinkling, and had dropped me apiece of the tent-cloth and pulled me to the top.  We found ourselves in the back yard of a private dwelling, and working our way toward the street were attacked by a ferocious bull-dog, whose howling alarmed us even more than his bite.  The cur quickly yielded to Ben’s suavity and caresses and left us for his mat on the doorstep.  In glancing over the front fence we were startled to see a sentry standing with his piece at order arms only a few feet away on the brick sidewalk!  There was nothing for it but to put a bold face on the matter and leap the fence.  Hastily agreeing to meet at a neighboring street light, Thompson was first and coolly walked away whistling.  In ten minutes I followed without the whistle, and shortly rejoined Ben at the appointed place.  Just why that “Johnny” failed to challenge us we never knew, but the probability in that overcome by drowsiness he was stealing a nap over his gun.  As neither of us had more than a general knowledge of the streets, such as we could gain by our first march through them, or by our study from the prison windows, we tramped on with only the vague notion of reaching the suburbs and concealing ourselves until the succeeding night.  Now and then we passed a watchman or some belated traveler, but the pieces of tent-cloth we had brought along so completely disguised us that no one asked any questions.  As hour’s hard tramping found us bewildered, and once more in the heart of the city.  Affairs took a serious turn.

We dared not inquire of those we me, nor at the houses, but hurrying on at our best pace found ourselves in another hour climbing the parapets of the third or inner line of works surrounding the city of the north.  We saw no troops, as most of the rebels were with Lee guarding the Petersburg front.  The ditch in front of the works was deep and half-filled with water, but creeping along in the darkness we soon reached a log laid over the chasm for the use of their troops.  Over this we were threading our dizzy way, when Ben, who was ahead, slipped and tumbled in.  He disappeared for a moment, but soon came up puffing to the surface.  I ran along the bank and dropping him my canvas soon fished him out to terra firma.  Every rag of clothing on him was saturated, and the bread in his pockets converted into mush.  Faint streaks of dawn now showing themselves admonished us to be pushing on, and despite Ben’s condition we hurried away for something that looked like woods in the distance.  We found the woods a swamp, thick grown with trees and underbrush.  Exhausted and faint, we found a spot somewhat more solid that the rest, where we lay down in the shelter of a large cottonwood tree.  After an hour’s sleep we both woke shivering and chilled to the very marrow.  Ben was the worse off; the result of his morning’s dunking.  To add to our discomfort a drizzling rain set in, and I was soon as badly off as my companion.  We dared not light a fire even if we had the means; the most we could venture on was to rise occasionally to our feet, stretch our benumbed and aching limbs, and return quietly to our drenched beds on the ground.  Soon after noon the sky cleared somewhat, and sounds of voices began to be heard; these indicated the presence of a camp on the opposite side of the swamp.  Not long after, the men seemed to start a hunt, and some dogs had evidently treed an animal.  Soon we heard the clip of axes, the tree was felled, and then dogs and men pushed on for the interior of the swamp.  Nearer and nearer they drew to our hiding place, and in a moment I saw the gray squirrel they were after dart into a hollow oak not three rods from us.  Three dogs and fifteen or twenty men were close behind.  We fugitives instinctively hug the sod beneath us.  Foiled in the chase, the men gather sticks and dry grass or bark and started a fire in the hollow but.  The smoke soon force the squirrel from his retreat, and with a leap he took to the nearest trees; the dogs rushed over in hot chase, but failed to molest us; the men taking a shorter cut avoided us altogether, and in a few moments we knew by their shouts that they had bagged their game and were on there way to camp.  In was a narrow chance, and Ben remarked, as we began to recover breath, that if that was a specimen of what we were to encounter the probabilities of our escape were slim.  Darkness, or best friend, came at last, and we crept out of our hiding place as fast as our chilled and stiffened limbs allowed.  With the pole star as guide we steered northward, in order if possible to cross the Chickahominy and put that stream between us and any pursuers that might be on our track.  Carefully avoiding the roads, except when it was necessary to cross them, we tramped on through the weary hours of the night, startled now and then by the snapping of a twig or the movement of some animal more frightened than ourselves.  At times we were up to the knees in mud and water, and again were climbing steep banks, or working our painful way through thickets and underbrush where we suffered severely from the thorns and briers.  Near dawn we crossed a second and less pretentious line of parapets and were rejoiced to find these, like the last, unoccupied by troops.  Soon after, we crept up to the Negro quarters of a Virginia plantation and stealthily pushing in the door we entered.  At one end of the room was a large fireplace, and stretched on the floor of unbaked clay, in a half-circle, were the dusky forms of half a dozen slaves, with heads turned toward the fire that was smoldering low on the hearth.  After some vigorous shaking we succeeded in rousing the sleepers, and begged for a chance to dry and warm ourselves.  

(continued next month)